You as American political leader

warning: this one’s passionate, fact-based, but a bit long 🙁

Everyday Leadership definitionally asserts: everyone can lead. In our representative democracy, this is a tautology: citizens not kings are leaders. One of the complaints I hear a lot is that elected leaders are more like elected . . . followers, “with their finger in the air” trying to know which way the wind is blowing. Yet this is in many respects how it should be. We should be telling them where we want them to go.  If they aren’t going in that direction we should mobilize ourselves to be more persuasive and more active; we should change the direction in which the winds blow.

I haven’t been doing a good job of political leadership. And seeing my wife Jennifer at her senate confirmation hearing this week to become Secretary of Energy inspired me.  So I offer four contrarian ideas to help us lead the country in a better direction:

  1. Discard the childish view that “all politicians suck.” It was not only our “democratic institutions” that survived January 6, as if those institutions are some disembodied, magical theory cranked up in the late 1700s by some old white-hairs that runs like a machine. Call me a blasphemer, but there are great political servants – at all levels. I consume the same political junk food as you do. So, it hit me hard this week when I realized that I had almost forgotten – gotten brain-washed amnesia – about the great people I have seen in politics – from my city councilman dad in 1969, to working for a congressman in 1992, to the state legislators whom I would meet in Lansing for lunch or at prayer breakfasts. I admired them – for their work ethic, intellect, and good will.  Every one of them has an ego, but last time I checked, so does everyone reading this blog. 

As I shadowed Jen on Wednesday, I felt ashamed at how both partisan and cynical I have become – and how I have become part of the problem. I was inspired by three things I saw:

  • Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski was praised by senators from both
    Senators Manchin and Murkowski conferring during climate change hearing
    parties for how she had run the Energy Committee with Joe Manchin of the other party.  (Another example of the power and necessity of “leading by 2.”)
  • Michigan Congressman Fred Upton from the party opposing my wife celebrated her work and character as he introduced her to his counterparts.
  • Senators and my wife, from coal and oil and auto and natural gas states, openly discussed one of the most intractable challenges that gets oversimplified and used by both sides to generate the politics of fear. They all agreed: the climate is changing and the market is shifting to renewables and technology. And they are all struggling with what we do for the workers whose lives depend on those older jobs while attacking new, longer term solutions. There was a genuine compassion for everyone’s American constituents and respect for the difficult intellectual and political challenges that they all face. I think you would have been inspired by the spirit there. 

I don’t know whether I can transfer to you just a smidge of my appreciation for public servants. Are some abusers of the system? Of course! Are there spectacular ethical heroes?  Yes. Just like in the rest of our lives. But my point is there are people, great people in our city halls, state legislatures and congress, and we are all just a little bit responsible for what happened on January 6th, because we have all contributed to the trashing of American democracy and America’s elected democrats (small d). 

2.  If we are serious about American democracy, we have to grow up to lead better. You and I are one of:

331,002,651 people

It is juvenile, if not infantile, to think a local representative, let alone a representative, senator or governor should see every issue the way you or I see it. Our increasingly segregated echo chambers reinforce our views and manipulate our emotions. They provoke our anxiety, our fear and over-stimulate our need for our tribe and our need to be right to protect us from “them.”  So, FOX and MSNBC say, and we amplify that (a) we are in danger, (b) we are right, (c) the other side are all “idiots, narcissists, socialists or fascists.” (Such name-calling is definitionally juvenile.) And (d) that it should somehow be easy for elected political leaders to solve our complex problems.  

So, I suggest:

3.   Wean yourself from your favorite source of political junk food. I’m generally a progressive, but I’ve just about eliminated my intake of CNN and MSNBC. I’m tired of their playing to my outrage, hopelessness, and fear. They talk about division, as if it’s been caused by the politicians. But let me tell the truth about them: They LIVE OFF and stoke and feed political division with nearly every “breaking news” story. They want you pissed off, waiting for the next horror story about some looney tune legislator. They pour flames on the fires that divide us at one moment, and then they innocently ask Pelosi or McCarthy why they keep being inflammatory. Consider this:  If Pelosi and McCarthy, Schumer and McConnell made progress – let alone reached a deal on the Covid stimulus bill this week – how long do you think MSNBC and FOX would report on that? 

4. Get some good news. I don’t mean happy news.  I mean quality news. See the Media Bias Chart below from a group called Ad Fortes Media if you want to know who you can trust. Left and right on the graph reflect left and right political slants. And top and bottom reflect the substantiation, from the most fact-based at the top to the lowest which are “selective, incomplete, unfair persuasion, or propaganda.”   

I suspect that you are so steeped in believing your team or tribe that you may read this chart (as I confess I did), looking for how your team is better and theirs is worse. But it’s impossible to avoid the truth that comes from a first-look or a deeper dive: the more your sources are directionally “down” and “out” on the chart, the more you’re making yourself subject to “confirmation bias,” hearing only what reinforces what you already believe. And, the more YOU are LEADING America down a path of division.

Get the true facts, engage in honest, curious dialogue and Lead America

with your best self. 

  • Well done, Dan. Thank you.
    The challenge continues before us: moving forward, together. Calling forth the best, the truest, the most positive actions and ideologies for ALL of our country and, ultimately, the whole world.

  • I LOVE how you challenge yourself and then us/me! Can’t wait to see what the next 4 years bring. I’m excited.

  • You have gone too far with CNN, MSNBC, FOX. Not all who appear on any of these should be discarded. Each have some good reporters, even excellent reporters. Then there are the commentators who pry into our emotions provoking anger and disgust. Some channels have less news and more opinion / commentary and out right bloviating. One problem they all have is pairing the bloviators with reporters on some panels. As not all politicians are corrupt, et cetera, not all who appear on these channels also fit that mold.
    Members of the 2 major parties generally have different psychological profiles, which has been studied and written about, which is all I will say about that here, otherwise I would write a short book.

  • >